Skip to content
All articles

Local & Community

Scranton's Century Homes and the Rebuild-Cost Gap

By David Bartal 6 min read

A renewal notice shows up in November for a three-story house in Green Ridge. The premium went up a little, the dwelling limit went up a little, and the owner files it with the others. The limit on that page started life as a number somebody entered when the house was bought, maybe fifteen years ago, and every year since it has been nudged by a percentage. Nobody has walked through the house and asked what it would really take to build it again.

That is the rebuild-cost gap, and it tends to be widest on exactly the kind of house this city has a lot of. Plenty of homes in Green Ridge, Hyde Park and the older blocks across Lackawanna County are a hundred years old or close to it. They were built with materials and methods that are expensive to reproduce, and they were built before most of today’s building code existed.

We covered the basic idea, insuring for replacement cost rather than sale price, in how much homeowners insurance you actually need. This post is about the specific places where an older house falls behind, and what to look at on your own policy.

Where the dwelling number usually comes from

When a home policy is written, the dwelling limit is typically produced by a replacement cost estimator. Someone enters the square footage, the year built, the number of stories, the roof type and a handful of quality and feature settings, and the software returns a figure.

That works reasonably well for a house that looks like most other houses. It gets shakier on an older one. If the inputs said “standard” finishes when the house actually has plaster walls, original hardwood, built-ins, a slate roof or a full walk-up attic, the estimate can come in low from day one. Annual inflation adjustments then build on that starting point. A low number that grows by a few percent a year is still a low number.

The fix is not complicated. The estimate needs better inputs, and that usually means someone asking more questions than the original quote did.

Rebuilding to today’s code costs more than rebuilding the original

Here is the part that surprises people. If a large part of an older house is damaged, the local building department will generally require the rebuilt portion to meet current code. That can mean updated electrical service and wiring, different framing and fire blocking, modern egress windows, stair dimensions, insulation and more, depending on what the code official requires for that project.

A standard home policy typically pays to rebuild what was there. The added cost of bringing it up to code is a separate question, and it is often handled by a coverage usually called ordinance or law. Many policies include a small amount of it, sometimes expressed as a percentage of the dwelling limit, and many carriers let you buy more. Some policies also address the cost of tearing down an undamaged portion that the code no longer allows to stand.

How much ordinance or law coverage your policy includes, and how it is triggered, varies by carrier and by policy form. On a house built around the turn of the last century, it is one of the first things worth reading on the declarations page.

The insure-to-value condition

Many homeowners policies carry a condition that matters even on a small claim. To be paid full replacement cost on a partial loss, the dwelling limit generally has to be at least a set percentage of the home’s full replacement cost. Eighty percent is common on standard forms, though carriers and forms differ.

If the limit falls below that threshold, the policy may pay less than the full cost of the repair, even when the repair itself is nowhere near the limit. So an underinsured older house can come up short on a kitchen fire as well as a total loss. That is a strong reason to keep the dwelling figure honest even if you consider a total loss unlikely.

Options that can close part of the gap

There are a few tools carriers use here. Which ones are available depends heavily on the carrier, the age and condition of the house, and the state.

  • Extended replacement cost adds a cushion above the dwelling limit, usually stated as a percentage, for situations where rebuilding costs more than expected.
  • Inflation guard adjusts the dwelling limit each year. It helps keep pace with construction costs, but it only adjusts whatever number you started with.
  • Some carriers offer functional or modified replacement cost on older homes. It pays to rebuild with modern materials that do the same job (drywall in place of plaster, for example) rather than reproducing the original exactly. That can make coverage more affordable, and it also means the rebuilt house would not be the same house. Some owners are fine with that trade and some are not.

None of these replaces getting the base number right. They work best on top of an accurate estimate.

What to gather before a review

If you want to check where your house stands, a little preparation makes the conversation much more useful:

  • Your current declarations page, so we can see the dwelling limit, the settlement terms and any ordinance or law coverage.
  • Finished square footage on each floor, including a finished attic or basement.
  • The details an estimator might have missed: plaster walls, original trim and woodwork, built-ins, hardwood, a slate or tile roof, a stone foundation, a porch.
  • Updates and their approximate years: roof, electrical, plumbing, heating. These matter both for the rebuild estimate and for how carriers view the house.
  • Anything you have added since the policy started, such as a bathroom, a kitchen remodel or a finished basement.

Photos of the interior help, too. They are useful for the estimate now and useful again if you ever have a claim.

Older houses here also deal with ice dams and frozen pipes on top of all this, which we went through in our post on what a home policy covers for ice dams and frozen pipes. A claim from either one is a common moment for an owner to find out what the dwelling limit really is.

Why renewal season is the time to look

A renewal is the natural point to change the dwelling limit or add coverage, and it is far easier to adjust before a loss than to argue about one after. If you own an older home in Scranton and the limit has only ever moved by the inflation adjustment, it is worth a second look. Our Pennsylvania home insurance page lays out the main parts of a home policy if you want the overview first.

As an independent agency, we can compare how several carriers estimate rebuild cost on older homes, which ones offer extended replacement cost or additional ordinance or law coverage, and what each option costs. We can’t tell you what your house would cost to rebuild without looking at it, and we won’t guess. We can sit down with you and the details and get to a number you can stand behind.

Call the office at 570-344-0211, text 570-487-3386, or send us your declarations page and we will go through it with you.

This article is general information, not insurance advice. Replacement cost estimates, insure-to-value conditions, ordinance or law coverage and extended replacement cost options vary by carrier, by policy form and by state. Talk with a licensed agent at Bartal Insurance about your home and your policy before making a decision.

Keep Reading

More from the blog.

Want a second look at your coverage?

A quick, no-pressure review with a local agent can catch gaps before they matter. We're right here in Scranton.

Request a free review

Or call 570-344-0211 / Text 570-487-3386